Jul 14 2008
Blue Ribbon Sushi for Dinner
I’m surprised at the high (8.4 out of 10) reader rating that Blue Ribbon Sushi in Soho got. However, I’m not surprised that not many of the reviews talked about the actual dining experience or the quality of the fish. Well, that just goes to show you that people who write reviews for these kinds of places… are not knowledgeable about sushi at all.
Anyway, I was expecting a lot and was severely disappointed, perhaps because I had high expectations to begin with. But I don’t think that was what went wrong, since I expect a lot out of so called “great” sushi places. I went with a friend to dinner and found the decor pleasant. The only thing I don’t like is the lack of reservations, though we got there early enough for there not to be a wait.
The menu was enticing. Lots of items (and wow that sake list) to offer, though a bit lacking on variety, though I haven’t been to any place that offered more variety than Sushi Yasuda. That aside, the menu offered lots of choices, for the connoisseur or the clueless. Also, Blue Ribbon Sushi doesn’t just offer sushi, there are quite a number of appetizers and non-sushi dishes to pick from.
I went with the daikon (radish) salad, sushi deluxe, a piece of botan ebi sushi (one of my favorites, I love shellfish sushi), and one of the specials that day, whole live clam - I didn’t feel like paying $65 for the omakase for a first time visit. Yes, I eat a lot, if you didn’t get that already from my previous posts. My friend got the Honoo set, essentially 3 spicy rolls. She was also going to get the Iwashi Special but they didn’t have it that day.
The service was adequate and prompt, so no complaints there. But as I mentioned above, the food just wasn’t as good as I expected. Fresh it was fresh. But the portion size was a bit small for the price I paid. Granted, the omakase might have offered some exciting varieties but from where I sat at the bar, I didn’t see any fish out of the ordinary. Their a la carte menu was also scarce in terms of variety. All in all, my Blue Ribbon Sushi experience was less adventurous as I had hoped. Sushi fans, stick to Sushi Yasuda for value and variety and Sushi of Gari if you want something fancier and are on a corporate expense account (or are just loaded).
